Why Arent PLCs Used for Building Controllers?
PLC（可编程逻辑控制器）在建筑控制领域的应用相对较少，这主要源于PLC的设计和特性并不完全适合建筑控制需求。PLC通常被设计为处理简单的逻辑任务，如开关控制或传感器监控，而不是复杂的建筑控制需求，如温度控制或能源管理。PLC通常不具备像建筑控制器那样的专业功能，如能源审计、自动化维护或建筑自动化系统的集成。PLC的编程语言和协议通常与建筑控制器不兼容，这也限制了其在该领域的应用。尽管PLC在建筑控制领域的应用受到限制，但它们在其他领域，如工业控制或交通控制中，仍然发挥着重要作用。
In the world of automation and building management, PLCs (Programmable Logic Controllers) are widely used for various applications. However, when it comes to building controllers, PLCs are not as common as one might expect. There are several reasons why PLCs are not typically employed for building controllers, including cost, complexity, and specialized requirements.
Cost
One of the main reasons why PLCs are not used for building controllers is cost. PLCs are typically more expensive than other types of controllers, such as relays or microcontrollers. While the initial cost of a PLC may be higher, the long-term benefits of using a PLC, such as its reliability and scalability, are often seen as justifying the additional cost. However, in the case of building controllers, the cost savings associated with using relays or microcontrollers may be significant enough to outweigh the benefits of using a PLC.
Complexity
Another reason why PLCs are not typically employed for building controllers is complexity. PLCs are complex devices that require specialized knowledge and training to program and troubleshoot. While this complexity may not be an issue in some applications, it can become a significant challenge when dealing with large or complex buildings. The complexity of PLCs also adds to their cost and makes them more difficult to implement and maintain.
Specialized Requirements
A final reason why PLCs are not used for building controllers is specialized requirements. Building controllers often need to interface with a variety of sensors, actuators, and other devices that may not be natively supported by a PLC. In these cases, additional hardware and software may be needed to enable the PLC to communicate with these devices, further increasing the cost and complexity of using a PLC for building control.
However, it is important to note that there are some cases where using a PLC for building control may be beneficial. For example, if a building has complex control requirements or needs to interface with a large number of sensors and actuators, a PLC may be able to provide the necessary processing power and flexibility to meet these demands. Additionally, PLCs are often used in applications where reliability and scalability are crucial, such as in industrial or commercial buildings where the cost of downtime or maintenance is high.
In conclusion, while PLCs are not typically employed for building controllers due to cost, complexity, and specialized requirements, there are some cases where their use may be beneficial. When considering whether to use a PLC for building control, it is important to weigh the costs and benefits based on the specific application and requirements of the building being managed.
Articles related to the knowledge points of this article：
Microcontroller-Based PLC: The Key to Modern Automation